The Myth of the Big Backyard and Dog Exercise

the daily dish More on PawNation: Doggie Fitness, Dogs, Exercise, Lifestyle, Puppies, Safety

The most persistent disconnect that I have encountered in 30 years of veterinary practice is the owner perception that if they have a fenced, large backyard, then their dog is active. I have lost count of the number of veterinary exams that feel like the movie Groundhog Day, where I live the same scene over and over.

For example: I am in an exam room and an overweight dog is lying on the floor in the exam room and hasn't moved in the first 10 minutes of the history-taking portion of my exam process. When I finally do get to the issue of weight and exercise information the owner insists that this immobile lump of canine at my feet is an unbelievable athlete when it is alone in the backyard.

RELATED: The Hardest Decision

As I try to elicit some voluntary movement from my patient that would help me perform my physical exam, the owner rambles on about how this dog is a perpetual motion machine in the backyard. I finish my exam in a pant due to efforts to move my patient. Attempts to convince the owner that this pet is not fit and really needs more exercise are unsuccessful. I complete the needs of the appointment and eagerly enter the next room for my next exam and encounter another immobile lump of canine athlete that also lives in a house with a big backyard.

A big backyard does not equal an active dog, yet the belief persists. Why?

RELATED: My Dog Needs A Dental - What About Yours?

Dr. Ernie Ward, in his book Chow Hounds, examined this misconception. He notes that when they are initially put out in the backyard, dogs naturally run the perimeter of the yard to ensure the family "pack" borders have not been breached by intruders. The owner sees this as they turn and close the door to return inside and leave the dog to exercise. Finally when the owner opens the door, the dog is at full steam returning to the owner. As Dr. Ward writes about the owner response ("Wow, that dog never slows down!") without realizing that the dog did nothing but lay around the yard during its entire time alone.

Other researchers have confirmed that pet dogs and wild dogs spend most of their time resting. For wild dogs it is a way of conserving energy between scarce meals. The behavior has not changed with domestication. A study in 1992 confirmed that solitary dogs rest 80 percent of their alone time, while multiple dogs rest 60 percent of the time. Dogs, like humans, need a reason to exercise. Although multiple dogs in a confined yard may play more than the solitary dog, owners still overestimate the amount of their activity.

If it wasn't measured, it didn't happen.

Dogs are pack animals and if the human members of the pack provide company and a reason to exercise, they will. Walking, fetching, swimming with the family (or as a family member watches), agility courses, etc., will motivate dogs to move. Time is measurable.

RELATED: Temperament Testing For Shelter Dogs And Cats

Time alone, however, is not the only component of productive exercise that burns calories. Dr. Ward notes that a stroll with a dog, although a great social event between dog and owner, is inadequate to burn meaningful calories. Dr. Ward researched data from NASA and other studies on exercise in dogs that indicate that a pace of 4-4.7 miles an hour, or 14-15 minute miles, are necessary for meaningful cardiovascular effects and caloric burn. Owners who are unable to walk at this pace will need to substitute fetching, agility, or swimming activities that are more cardiovascular intense. Ideally these strategies should be a daily event for at least an hour.

Dr. Ken Tudor

The Myth of the Big Backyard and Dog Exercise originally appeared on

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

1 Comment

Filter by:

Great post. Thanks Dr. Ken.
We at have worked with our vets and done the research (Waltham Centre, etc) and have created an App that provides dog owners with some guidelines on how much they should feed their dog, given how active the dog is.

SlimDoggy, a "Nike + or RunKeeper for dogs", is based on our experience with Jack- a Yellow Lab that we rescued in August 2011. He was 105 lbs. and on both Prozac (for anxiety & hyperactivity) and Rimadyl. Jack was ‘unadoptable’- he was in the shelter for over a year before we took a chance on him. We knew we had to change his lifestyle and his weight to get him into a good, healthy state. Once we knew how much to feed him each day, it was a matter of less than 3 months before Jack was down to 85 lbs, off of both medications, and is now a happy and healthy dog.

Little did we know that there are a lot of dogs like Jack: there are 41 million overweight/obese dogs in the US[1] and the incremental cost in vet/medicine bills for this is an estimated $6-8 billion annually. Upon learning these startling statistics, we decided to share our work and create an iPhone App (Android version coming soon) and attack the dog obesity problem head on.

Like the Apps used by humans, SlimDoggy is meant to work in conjunction with your vet-- make sure to get a checkup and discuss any proposed lifestyle/exercise/feeding changes.

Furthermore, by tracking feeding/activity and weight history, it will be easier to diagnose when something other than over/under feeding is causing undue weight changes.

For all of the above reasons, our local vets are supporting us and recommending our App to their clients.

Read more about it at http:/

February 22 2013 at 7:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Who is Cutest?

Like us on Facebook?
Next Paws
Meet Trotter Pup