How Pit Bulls Got Singled Out as Dangerous Dogs
the daily dish
You've probably heard nightmarish stories about Pit bulls and their supposedly dangerous natures. You may even have friends who own dogs but still believe that Pit bulls are unsafe and to be avoided. As animal lovers, we know by now that Pit bulls are not "killer dogs," or monsters more dangerous than any other breed. But it's frustrating to see so much misinformation persist. How did Pit bulls go from being a trusted breed years ago to one that is hated, vilified and feared today?
According to an article on Alternet, it wasn't long ago that Pit bulls not only weren't feared, but with their friendly and patient temperaments, were actually considered to be a perfect "nanny breed" for children. But in the 1980s, the breed began to develop a terrible reputation. It's not clear where the cycle started, but at some point, Pit bulls became the dog breed of choice for the criminal element, or those looking for dogs to threaten, guard, intimidate and generally look scary. This led to many owners abusing their Pit bulls into becoming vicious, mean attack dogs. The breed's reputation worsened, thus encouraging more people in the market for "mean" dogs to adopt Pit bulls, and the catch-22 was in place.
Of course, there's no hard evidence to support the idea that Pit bulls are naturally more aggressive or dangerous than other breeds. Myths about their super-powerful bite force and dangerous "locking jaws" are likewise utterly fabricated. Pit bulls don't even have jaw strength as powerful as other breeds like Mastiffs, whose jaws clamp down with much greater force, but somehow haven't cursed them with an image as killer dogs. The real facts show that Pit bulls are actually docile compared to other dogs. A study of dog breeds was conducted to gauge temperament by measuring skittishness, aggression and ability to differentiate between threatening and non-threatening humans. The results showed what Pit bull lovers of the past knew: the "nanny breed" was among the friendliest and least aggressive. Aggressive Pit bulls are almost always the products of abuse, neglect or both. It is irresponsible breeders and owners who are to blame for the breed's negative image.
But the Alternet article points out that the media's ongoing willingness to sell out Pit bulls doesn't help matters. News outlets are quick to support the belief that Pit bulls are dangerous, because it allows for sensationalized stories, stories that won't go over if their audiences don't believe the misleading "facts" on which they are based. In a way, since the Pit bull's negative reputation is essentially an invention, it exists as a cultural meme, a persistent urban legend. Other breeds have trended similarly in the past. Rottweilers and Doberman Pinschers to some degree still deal with this. In the 19th century, it was Bloodhounds who were considered inherently dangerous. If that seems absurd to us now, it's because the idea then was based on the same lies that haunt Pit bulls today. It's gotten so bad that when dog attacks happen, the media will often identify the breed as a Pit bull even when it's not the case. And when Pit bulls do attack, it is often much more widely reported than similar attacks caused by other breeds.
Pit bulls' bad reputation has been so deeply ingrained in our culture that a kind of racism has developed against them. Mistrust leads to suspicious attention, which leads to the breed being implicated in more negative activity than other breeds, which worsens and perpetuates the breed's reputation. Governments and lawmakers, by creating absurd breed-specific bans, only serve to cement misinformed and bigoted beliefs. Even popular entertainers like Kelly Ripa are taken in by the media's portrayal of Pit bulls as bloodthirsty attack dogs, and in turn worsen the problem by perpetuating the stereotype.
But there's always hope, and increasingly, a growing backlash against Pit bull bigotry has more and more people learning that Pit bulls are perfectly safe and even very loving, loyal dogs. As Cesar Millan of "The Dog Whisperer" has grown famous for his canine expertise, his love of and support for Pit bulls has gone a long way to convincing a general audience that the breed's negative image is completely undeserved. Other popular shows like Shorty Rossi's "Pit Boss" add to the wave of positive Pit bull PR. And for every person who adopts a Pit bull and learns of its true nature, an entire network of family and friends in turn learns the truth. It's up to each of us to spread the real facts about Pit bulls.
WHAT ARE THE 12 MOST FREQUENTLY BANNED BREEDS?
According to an article on Alternet, it wasn't long ago that Pit bulls not only weren't feared, but with their friendly and patient temperaments, were actually considered to be a perfect "nanny breed" for children. But in the 1980s, the breed began to develop a terrible reputation. It's not clear where the cycle started, but at some point, Pit bulls became the dog breed of choice for the criminal element, or those looking for dogs to threaten, guard, intimidate and generally look scary. This led to many owners abusing their Pit bulls into becoming vicious, mean attack dogs. The breed's reputation worsened, thus encouraging more people in the market for "mean" dogs to adopt Pit bulls, and the catch-22 was in place.
Of course, there's no hard evidence to support the idea that Pit bulls are naturally more aggressive or dangerous than other breeds. Myths about their super-powerful bite force and dangerous "locking jaws" are likewise utterly fabricated. Pit bulls don't even have jaw strength as powerful as other breeds like Mastiffs, whose jaws clamp down with much greater force, but somehow haven't cursed them with an image as killer dogs. The real facts show that Pit bulls are actually docile compared to other dogs. A study of dog breeds was conducted to gauge temperament by measuring skittishness, aggression and ability to differentiate between threatening and non-threatening humans. The results showed what Pit bull lovers of the past knew: the "nanny breed" was among the friendliest and least aggressive. Aggressive Pit bulls are almost always the products of abuse, neglect or both. It is irresponsible breeders and owners who are to blame for the breed's negative image.
But the Alternet article points out that the media's ongoing willingness to sell out Pit bulls doesn't help matters. News outlets are quick to support the belief that Pit bulls are dangerous, because it allows for sensationalized stories, stories that won't go over if their audiences don't believe the misleading "facts" on which they are based. In a way, since the Pit bull's negative reputation is essentially an invention, it exists as a cultural meme, a persistent urban legend. Other breeds have trended similarly in the past. Rottweilers and Doberman Pinschers to some degree still deal with this. In the 19th century, it was Bloodhounds who were considered inherently dangerous. If that seems absurd to us now, it's because the idea then was based on the same lies that haunt Pit bulls today. It's gotten so bad that when dog attacks happen, the media will often identify the breed as a Pit bull even when it's not the case. And when Pit bulls do attack, it is often much more widely reported than similar attacks caused by other breeds.
Pit bulls' bad reputation has been so deeply ingrained in our culture that a kind of racism has developed against them. Mistrust leads to suspicious attention, which leads to the breed being implicated in more negative activity than other breeds, which worsens and perpetuates the breed's reputation. Governments and lawmakers, by creating absurd breed-specific bans, only serve to cement misinformed and bigoted beliefs. Even popular entertainers like Kelly Ripa are taken in by the media's portrayal of Pit bulls as bloodthirsty attack dogs, and in turn worsen the problem by perpetuating the stereotype.
But there's always hope, and increasingly, a growing backlash against Pit bull bigotry has more and more people learning that Pit bulls are perfectly safe and even very loving, loyal dogs. As Cesar Millan of "The Dog Whisperer" has grown famous for his canine expertise, his love of and support for Pit bulls has gone a long way to convincing a general audience that the breed's negative image is completely undeserved. Other popular shows like Shorty Rossi's "Pit Boss" add to the wave of positive Pit bull PR. And for every person who adopts a Pit bull and learns of its true nature, an entire network of family and friends in turn learns the truth. It's up to each of us to spread the real facts about Pit bulls.
WHAT ARE THE 12 MOST FREQUENTLY BANNED BREEDS?
You Say.…?
- button.wow
- button.lol
- button.aww
- button.poop



Add a Comment
225 Comments
heifer dust! I knew a man with a pit bull in the mid 70's who was proud that his dog was able to kill a german shepard when the pit bull was only two years old, It also got a poodle! They did not suddenly in the 80's start being mistreated, the criminal element wanted to protect themselves during drug deals. And the dog fulfilled the role, BECAUSE IT ALREADY HAD THOSE TENDENCIES!
May 06 2013 at 7:40 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI have3 Blue Heelers, 2 Rottweilers and 2 Pitt Bulls. When someone comes to visit I have to lock up the Blue Heelers because they bite and are very protective of me. More people are afraid of the Pitt Bulls and my wonderful Rottweilers but nobody bats an eye at the smaller dogs. Fact is, smaller breeds are more likely to bite than the bigger breeds, and they are the number one bitters of children. Anyone with a dog knows that when your dog bites your are held responsible for the actions of your dog, no matter the size or the breed. I know that Pitt Bulls are dangerouse but large breeds are when they latch on to a child and chew the child up, but they are not all like that. Bald men with gangster tattoo's are not killer gang members yet we treat them like they are. The good dogs need to start becoming more in numbers than the bad ones, one dog at a time? one owner at a time? Something needs to change but lets not give up on this breautiful breed.
May 06 2013 at 5:43 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyPit Bulls, Dobies, Rotties, Boxer, German Shepards, Staffordshire terriers, etc., get a bum rap. If these dogs are properly trained and socialied from day one, they will not attack. Those that are abused and trained to attack are "usually" done by ppl who are involved in illegal activities.
May 06 2013 at 5:12 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyPIT BULLS ARE GREAT DOGS AND A GREAT BREED and unfairly judged and criticized and I an tired of it. Our in laws have a Pure Bred Pit Bull and they have had it since he was a puppy and I grew up with a Labrador and adored her but the next dog I adopt for sure will be a Pit Bull !!!! Most of the dog attacks around our home have been by little dogs not the big ones and NOT PIT BULLS. Anyone who says such awful things about a specific breed has obviously never experienced having one in their life and until you have a Pit Bull and experience their Love and how much affection they have then shame on you for categorizing them as devil dogs. You need to educate yourself on all dog breeds. Oh and to put in bluntly............any dog breed can attack when provoked and YES A LOT OF HOW A DOG BEHAVES IS BASED ON HOW A HUMAN BEING RAISES THAT DOG AND TREATS THAT DOG. 99% of it falls on the OWNER !!!!!!!! Do your homework and stop judging PIts, Rotts, German Shepards, Mastiffs and all the other wonderful Large Breeds that get such bad raps. Leave the dogs alone and instead you should be bashing the owners who don't treat them properly and ignore them, mistreat them and abuse them. The owners are the ones who should be judged, not their dogs !!!!
May 06 2013 at 3:52 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyMy story begins by admitting that I too was one of those people who thought pitbulls were vicious dogs from all the media hype. To my surprise and horror my fiance decided to "surprise" me with an american pitbull puppy 3 years ago. And this is what I have to say about my experience the past 3 years: never have I ever felt the love, and loyalty of a creature such as my pittie has given me. He has been showered with love, belly rubs and treats. He did finish a 6 month obedience training, which I believe every single dog should do (even the little ones). He goes to the doggy park and plays with dogs of all sizes and breeds. When he was about 6 months old he was attacked and bitten by a Huski yet still to this day has not shown any aggression toward a single dog or human being. When other dogs show aggression toward him, he simply walks away. What I am trying to say is this: to all those people with misconceptions of this breed, please take some time out of your life, open your heart, go to your local pound and spend some time with a pitbull. I am 100% confident that you will change your mind just as my pittie has changed my life. You have not felt love and/or loyalty until you have opened your heart to a pitbull.
February 13 2013 at 2:43 PM Report abuse Permalink +2 rate up rate down ReplyREPLY TO: Nothing but a bunch of ignoramus dog hating people is what these idiots are true! They know nothing of the breed and so do some of the others here I am an ambassador to the breed having been around them my whole life and I'm not young I have the most beautiful dogs ever watch something good and stop making up crazy off the wall stories that only you in your mind believe wow you just sound so ignorant! ..It does no good to talk to these stupid people for they are far to out there..All I know is most are making up what they want to hear and stupid purple girl wow dogs killing people your out of your mind! You people here are all telling myths, made up stories no way could they be true same as if you shot a person in the head fricking crazies..In all my debate groups never have I heard such stupidity you all need to go get real!!!
February 13 2013 at 12:21 PM Report abuse Permalink +2 rate up rate down ReplyMy 3 year old Pit bull is Canine Good Citizen Certified and therapy dog certified. You closed minded people need to go away! Your stats are off, majority of the dogs are not even Pit Bulls or even the bully breed. I work at two shelters and I even had a lab come in that was labeled as a pit bull. I fight for this breed... the Nanny Dog! Breed Specific Legislation needs to freaking end now! I will only own a Pit bull!
February 12 2013 at 10:35 PM Report abuse Permalink +1 rate up rate down ReplyA civil court judge said on television last week that 90% of the cases involving dog attacks that she heard were by pit bulls. The attacks were primarily on children or other dogs
February 12 2013 at 1:22 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyL.A. NOW
February 11 2013 at 12:23 PM Report abuse Permalink +1 rate up rate down ReplySOUTHERN CALIFORNIA -- THIS JUST IN
Lancaster's dog ordinance is cited in helping to drive down gang crime January 21, 2010
A Lancaster ordinance imposing stiff penalties on owners of “potentially dangerous” and “vicious” dogs is reaping positive results, and may have even helped to drive down gang crime in the city, officials said.
The law, adopted in January 2009, was primarily aimed at preventing gang members from using dogs, such as pit bulls and Rottweilers, to bully people or cause physical harm, officials said.
City officials said that 1,138 pit bulls and Rottweilers were impounded last year by the Los Angeles County Department of Animal Care and Control. Of those, 362 were voluntarily surrendered by their owners in response to Lancaster’s ordinance.
“A year ago, this city was overrun with individuals -- namely, gang members -- who routinely used pit bulls and other potentially vicious dogs as tools of intimidation and violence,” Lancaster Mayor R. Rex Parris said in a statement.
“These individuals delighted in the danger these animals posed to our residents, often walking them without leashes and allowing them to run rampant through our neighborhoods and parks. Today, more than 1,100 of these animals have been removed from our city, along with the fear they create. Lancaster is now a great deal safer because of it.”
Parris believes there is a correlation between the results of the dog ordinance and a drop in the city’s gang crime rate. Lancaster’s violent gang crime, which includes homicide, rape, robbery and aggravated assault, fell by 45% last year, and there was a drop in overall gang crime by 41%, Parris said, citing statistics from the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department.
Under the dog ordinance, a hearing officer can deem a dog to be potentially dangerous, for example, if the animal becomes aggressive when unprovoked.
The dog can be impounded, and the owner must have it properly licensed, implanted with a microchip and vaccinated at his own cost before the animal’s release.
Dogs deemed to be vicious can be destroyed if they are determined to be a significant threat to public safety, according to the ordinance.
It also requires owners of potentially dangerous dogs to ensure proper leashing and muzzling, complete a dog obedience training course, spay or neuter their animals, and pay a fine of up to $500 for each offense.
Owners of dogs deemed to be vicious face fines of up to $1,000 per offense, and they could be prevented from possessing any dog for up to three years.
Though city officials praise the dog law, some residents continue to challenge its fairness. They argue that “breed-specific” legislation is an injustice to canines, because irresponsible owners are to blame for a dog’s behavior, not the dog.
-- Ann M. Simmons
wow you are so educated, you know how to copy and paste...good for you!!
February 13 2013 at 2:29 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyNo link between owners, aggressive dogs: Study.
February 11 2013 at 12:23 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyNanaimo Daily News [Nanaimo, B.C 24 May 2012.
More proof that is the breed not the owner, it is nature not nurture that creates a mutant undog killer like a pit bull.
People who love tough dogs may be as misunderstood as the animals themselves, if a new academic study is any indication.
Reporting in the journal Anthrozoos, researchers from Canada and the U.K. find an affinity for breeds perceived as aggressive - think Staffordshire bull terriers and boxers - isn't linked to delinquent behavior, despite stereotypes of such people as gang bangers, criminals and garden-variety dirt bags.
The only cliche that held true was one of anti-social tendencies: folks who were suspicious, unfriendly or competitive were likelier to desire an intimidating dog than their more affable counterparts.
Credit: News Services.
Copyright CanWest Digital Media May 24, 2012.